Emissions Trading / Carbon Market News (28/04/2025)

Dear Sir or Madam,

The development of carbon emissions from the German electricity mix can certainly be described as positive. While 764 grams of CO2 per kilowatt hour of electricity were emitted in 1990, last year the figure was only 363 grams, less than half. Ten years earlier, in 2014, the figure was 559 grams, and in the previous year, 2023, it was 386 grams. In 2022, the figure was 433 grams, according to the German Federal Environment Agency.

This development is particularly linked to the expansion of renewable energies, but also to the significant decline in electricity consumption. While consumption stood at 479 terawatt hours (TWh) in 1990, the year of German reunification, it rose steadily to 583 TWh by 2017. However, since 2018, electricity consumption has fallen for the first time to 573 TWh. In the first year of the coronavirus pandemic, 2020, consumption reached a temporary low of 513 terawatt hours, followed by an increase to 529 TWh in 2021.

In 2022, the year the war in Ukraine began, however, there was another decline to 516 TWh, followed by a significant drop of 12% to 454 terawatt hours in the following year. This trend continued in 2024 with a further decline to 439 TWh, despite the significant increase in e-mobility in the transport sector and the increased use of heat pumps in buildings.

Since the peak in 2017, electricity consumption in Germany has fallen by a good quarter in the past year. Some people may be pleased about this, but such a sharp decline in electricity consumption is linked to a sharp decline in demand in industrial production, which could only be offset by rising inflation, as can be seen when comparing this with the development of gross domestic product.

Only a visible increase in German electricity consumption will signal a turnaround in the German economy and an end to the downturn.

This has a monocausal impact on total emissions and, consequently, on the price of European emission allowances, given that Germany is the EU’s largest economy.

From this perspective, emission allowances have rightly fallen from their high of over 100 euros per EUA to their current level of between 60 and 70 euros per tonne.

In the past trading week, which was shortened to four days, EUAs traded in a range between 63.61 and 67.63 euros in the December 25 benchmark contract and closed with a slight gain of 0.8% at 66.43 euros.

Due to the public holiday, only three auctions will take place at the EEX this week, from Monday to Wednesday, at which 8,563,500 EUAs will be auctioned. This represents a small increase of 5.74% compared to the previous week, in which only three auctions took place due to Easter Monday.

Instrument17/04/2525/04/25Change
EUA (December-25-Future)65.89 EUR66.43 EUR+0.54 EUR
nEZ (national Emission Allowances (D))55.00 EUR55.00 EUR+0.00 EUR
UKA (December-25-Future (UK))47.16 GBP47.46 GBP+0.30 GBP
UK Natural Gas (December-25-Future)98.39 GBP89.82 GBP-8.57 GBP
ICE Brent Crude Oil (December-25-Future)65.11 USD64.40 USD-0.71 USD
EURO (Forex)1.1372 USD1.1363 USD-0.0009 USD

(EUA. UKA, Natural Gas, Crude Oil and Euro Currency shows day-end-exchange quotes of the benchmark contract. This market information has just an informational character and are no advice or offer to trade emission allowances or their futures and options. If you want to unsubscribe, please reply to this mail.)

Please call our international carbon desk if any further questions exist: +49.2831.1348220.

With kind regards,

Your Advantag – Team

Emissions Trading / Carbon Market News (22/04/2025)

Dear Sir or Madam,

While the European Commission expects the price of emission allowances in the EU ETS II to be €45 when it starts in 2027 and €60 in 2030, an analysis by the EWI (Energy Economics Institute at the University of Cologne) sees the need for a more ambitious price path for the new European emissions trading system.

The analysis by the team led by project manager Philipp Artur Kienscherf sees prices of more than €160 per tonne of CO2 as possible, which is significantly above the European Commission’s price expectations.

The analysis also shows that a carbon price of less than €250 in 2030 will not be sufficient to achieve the decarbonisation targets for the building and transport sectors. At the same time, the analysts pointed out that accompanying measures, such as subsidy programmes and social compensation, would be helpful in achieving the goals of the Fit-for-55 programme.

With the market stability reserve, the EU has already created an instrument in EU ETS I that will also be used in EU ETS II. The legislator intends to use this to keep prices low in 2027. In the first year, certificates will be auctioned through frontloading at a volume of 130% of the auctioned volume. The additional 30% will then be auctioned to a lesser extent in the years 2029 to 2031.

In addition, 20 million additional allowances are to be auctioned if the price exceeds 45 euros in two consecutive months, 50 million if the price is twice the six-month average of the previous months in three consecutive months, and 150 million if the average price exceeds three times the previous six-month average in more than three consecutive months. However, such market intervention can only be used once within a 12-month period.

These regulations alone will lead to higher volatility, especially at the beginning, as intervention by the market stability reserve would only be possible in the third month after the start of trading under EU ETS II at the earliest. And if you look at the total certificate cap for 2027 of 1,036,288,784 emission allowances, an additional 20,000,000 are unlikely to have any long-term effect.

During the shortened Holy Week, prices recovered slightly in both the energy sector and EU emission allowances as the White House signalled a relaxation of US tariff policy.

This was probably triggered by Beijing’s show of strength in announcing an export ban on rare earths, which are essential to the computer industry and electromobility, both important sectors in the US.

Prices on the financial, commodity futures and energy markets will therefore continue to be influenced by global economic developments in the current week.

During the four days of this trading week, there will be three auctions on the EEX, at which 8,098,000 EUAs will be auctioned. In the following week, there will also be only three auction dates, as Thursday, 1 May, is a public holiday and the German auction will also be cancelled on Friday, as many people will be taking a long weekend.

Instrument11/04/2517/04/25Change
EUA (December-25-Future)64.82 EUR65.89 EUR+1.07 EUR
nEZ (national Emission Allowances (D))55.00 EUR55.00 EUR+0.00 EUR
UKA (December-25-Future (UK))46.23 GBP47.16 GBP+0.93 GBP
UK Natural Gas (December-25-Future)94.18 GBP98.39 GBP+4.21 GBP
ICE Brent Crude Oil (December-25-Future)62.50 USD65.11 USD+2.61 USD
EURO (Forex)1.1361 USD1.1372 USD+0.0011 USD

(EUA. UKA, Natural Gas, Crude Oil and Euro Currency shows day-end-exchange quotes of the benchmark contract. This market information has just an informational character and are no advice or offer to trade emission allowances or their futures and options. If you want to unsubscribe, please reply to this mail.)

Please call our international carbon desk if any further questions exist: +49.2831.1348220.

With kind regards,

Your Advantag – Team

Emissions Trading / Carbon Market News (14/04/2025)

Dear Sir or Madam,

Ships in Europe or those heading for European ports that are subject to the EU Emissions Trading System EU ETS I have been included in the pricing of greenhouse gas emissions since 2024.

Now, the member states of the International Maritime Organization (IMO) have agreed on a global system of carbon pricing in shipping, according to which all ships will be required to use low-carbon fuel mixes from 2028. In addition, annually decreasing emission limits have been set until 2035.

The revenues are to be used to benefit developing countries in particular, and incentives are to be created for the use of palm and soybean oil as well as e-fuels.

Even if it is hard to believe, global shipping is only responsible for just under 3% of global greenhouse gas emissions.

Last week, carbon emission allowances in the EU ETS I again showed high volatility due to the erratic customs policy of the incumbent US president. The EUA benchmark contract moved in a range of 60.07 to 65.33 euros, and both investors and taxable companies were able to take the opportunity to cover themselves at low prices.

As we wrote in our previous carbon market report, one could assume that Donald Trump would pull off another volte-face, which he did last week. He suspended a large proportion of the new tariffs for many countries for a period of 90 days.

Since he had previously issued a buy recommendation for stocks, which then reacted strongly bullish, it would be only logical for the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to investigate this with regard to insider information or even insider trading by the president or people close to him.

Trump also raised tariffs on China to 145%, to which Beijing responded with a countermeasure of 125% in total.

At some point, a voice of reason or capital seems to have penetrated to him, which is why he exempted smartphones, computers and semiconductor products on Saturday.

Today, Donald Trump will attempt to provide an explanation. Further developments in this confusing tariff dispute will be the main driver of movement in the global financial, commodity and energy markets this week, and we expect volatility to remain high.

On Good Friday, the German auction at the EEX will not take place, which is why a total of 11,809,000 EUAs will be auctioned this week.

In the following week, there will be no auction on Easter Monday, and since the Polish Wednesday auction will also be not available, the auction volume will be reduced to a total of 8,098,000 emission rights, the lowest weekly volume so far this year.

    
Instrument04/04/2511/04/25Change
EUA (December-25-Future)63.82 EUR64.82 EUR+1.00 EUR
nEZ (national Emission Allowances (D))55.00 EUR55.00 EUR+0.00 EUR
UKA (December-25-Future (UK))43.28 GBP46.23 GBP+2.95 GBP
UK Natural Gas (December-25-Future)97.98 GBP94.18 GBP-3.80 GBP
ICE Brent Crude Oil (December-25-Future)63.57 USD62.50 USD-1.07 USD
EURO (Forex)1.0964 USD1.1361 USD+0.0397 USD

(EUA. UKA, Natural Gas, Crude Oil and Euro Currency shows day-end-exchange quotes of the benchmark contract. This market information has just an informational character and are no advice or offer to trade emission allowances or their futures and options. If you want to unsubscribe, please reply to this mail.)

Please call our international carbon desk if any further questions exist: +49.2831.1348220.

With kind regards,

Your Advantag – Team

Emissions Trading / Carbon Market News (07/04/2025)

Dear Sir or Madam,

The US government’s tariffs on almost all countries around the globe and the counter-tariffs announced by China last Friday have turned the financial markets deep red in the past week.

The Japanese Nikkei Index lost 7.30% last week, the DAX 7.24% and the Dow Jones 7.41%, with Friday alone accounting for 5.50%. The US technology index NASDAQ Composite was particularly hard hit, falling 8.55%, last Friday’s announcement of the Chinese counter-tariffs led to a loss of 5.82%.

In view of the current market situation, it is difficult to make a clear forecast for the coming weeks. Future market developments will depend heavily on geopolitical events and the decisions of central banks.

Even the US government’s special adviser, Tesla boss Elon Musk, spoke out in favour of abolishing all tariffs between the US and Europe, thus taking a clear stand against Donald Trump’s policies.

Since the last-named is extremely erratic and protests against his policies are visibly increasing in the US, it cannot be ruled out that he will make another U-turn in the not too distant future, which would lead to a corresponding counter-reaction by the financial markets.

And the commodity markets have also weakened considerably due to concerns about the global economy. Last week, Brent crude lost 8.69%, UK gas lost 6.67% and EU ETS I emission allowances fell by 7.24% on a weekly basis.

Depending on how the situation surrounding US tariffs and possible EU countermeasures develops, the extremely nervous financial markets and, consequently, the commodity and energy markets will move in the coming weeks.

For EUAs, this means that prices will also be restrained and that it looks like a good opportunity for companies subject to the levy to procure at least part of the required quantities of certificates. Because should the chaos created by Trump subside, with him sending signals of détente and celebrating a ‘deal’ for himself, corresponding counterreactions will not be long in coming on the markets.

This week, 3,245,500 EUAs from the EU will be auctioned off on the European Energy Exchange (EEX) in Leipzig on Monday, Tuesday and Thursday, and 1,607,000 from Germany’s quota will be auctioned off on Friday.

    
Instrument28/03/2504/04/25Change
EUA (December-25-Future)68.80 EUR63.82 EUR-4.98 EUR
nEZ (national Emission Allowances (D))55.00 EUR55.00 EUR+0,00 EUR
UKA (December-25-Future (UK))44.59 GBP43.28 GBP-1.31 GBP
UK Natural Gas (December-25-Future)104.98 GBP97.98 GBP-7.00 GBP
ICE Brent Crude Oil (December-25-Future)69.62 USD63.57 USD-6.05 USD
EURO (Forex)1.0829 USD1.0964 USD+0.0135 USD

(EUA. UKA, Natural Gas, Crude Oil and Euro Currency shows day-end-exchange quotes of the benchmark contract. This market information has just an informational character and are no advice or offer to trade emission allowances or their futures and options. If you want to unsubscribe, please reply to this mail.)

Please call our international carbon desk if any further questions exist: +49.2831.1348220.

With kind regards,

Your Advantag – Team

Emissions Trading / Carbon Market News (31/03/2025)

Dear Sir or Madam,

France has called the European Union for a price corridor for CO2 emissions trading in order to limit volatility driven by speculation while still being in line with the EU’s greenhouse gas reduction targets.

The French Minister for Ecology, Energy, Sustainable Development and the Sea, Agnès Pannier-Runacher, explained that companies should be given long-term price signals so that they can adapt and plan ahead.

On the other hand, the Berlin think tank Agora Energiewende is calling for a minimum price in the EU ETS II. In its recently published policy brief “Course to Goal Achievement”, Agora recommends a minimum price of 90 euros when the EU ETS II is introduced in 2027. The target price set by the EU is between 48 and 80 euros.

In addition, Agora repeatedly proposes paying a climate allowance of 120 euros per person from 2026, which should then be scaled according to income in subsequent years. At present, this would correspond to about half of the revenue from national emissions trading system in Germany.

So far, however, there has been no information regarding the climate allowance in the current German coalition negotiations between the CDU/CSU and SPD.

Under pressure from further falling gas prices, the price of EU ETS emission allowances fell back below the 70 euro mark last week and ended the week down 3.7% on Friday.

Last Thursday, EUAs broke through the 200-day-line and moved towards the strong support level described in the last market report at just over 68 euros. On Friday, this technical support also held and the price recovered slightly to a closing price of 68.80 in the benchmark contract.

This week, auctions will be held on all five trading days on the EEX, with a total of 13,417,000 EUAs being auctioned.

    (Average Quotes Exchange / OTC)       
Instrument21/03/2528/03/25Change
EUA (December-25-Future)71.45 EUR68.80 EUR-2.65 EUR
nEZ (national Emission Allowances (D))55.00 EUR55.00 EUR+0.00 EUR
UKA (December-25-Future (UK))46.24 GBP44.59 GBP-1.65 GBP
UK Natural Gas (December-25-Future)109.03 GBP104.98 GBP-4.05 GBP
ICE Brent Crude Oil (December-25-Future)69.05 USD69.62 USD+0.57 USD
EURO (Forex)1.0816 USD1.0829 USD+0.0013 USD

(EUA. UKA, Natural Gas, Crude Oil and Euro Currency shows day-end-exchange quotes of the benchmark contract. This market information has just an informational character and are no advice or offer to trade emission allowances or their futures and options. If you want to unsubscribe, please reply to this mail.)

Please call our international carbon desk if any further questions exist: +49.2831.1348220.

With kind regards,

Your Advantag – Team